For Reynolds wheels, I have tried the yellow rim tape, Gorilla tape and the Reynolds Tubless Rim Tape. Keep in mind that this was my first experience with tubeless, but I found the Reynolds Tape to adhere and seal better than anything else I had tried.
I have had the wheels almost six months and the tape is holding well. The tires lose about 2 psi every two or three days, however in a submersion tank there are no obvious leaks.
I will reorder when necessary even thought the tape maybe a bit overpriced.